Stories & Reviews
Guestbook
“ Two out of the three pizza slices we got were delicious! The third was a little over cooked and dry but not bad. The service was friendly, quick and efficient! The atmosphere has beautiful wall decorations, wood tables and is clean. However, for us, it was a little to quiet. Loved watching the pizzas being made! ”
“ On the same really particular about pizza, I like flavor, but I like thin crust style and good toppings. I tried this pizza place because it was nearby where I live and my family and I have been completely addicted to it. We order almost every week, They are priced reasonably, and their pizza and wings are very good. ”
“ This pizzeria is the epitome of NY Style Pizza. A crispy outer crust, and soft and chewy on the inside. This tasty crust held up very well to the toppings. Each pizza had the right amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings. The tomato dipping sauce was garlicky, and one can easily, at least I can, get addicted to it. We enjoyed the cheese, pepperoni, Buffalo chicken, Margherita, and white and Meat Lover rollover pizzas slices. Each was delicious, flavorful, and could easily be folded in half (as they do in NY). We also ordered and enjoyed the Pepperoni Roll and Garlic Breadsticks. I also had a nice conversation with the owner and found out he is from Long Island. He's perfected the craft of creating the perfect NY Style Thin Crust Pizza, and it shows. The inside looks exactly like the pizzeria I am used to visiting in NJ and NY. Manhattan Pizzeria is the best NY Style Pizzeria in Indianapolis. An authentic and tasty version of NY style pizza and garlic knots. A crust that is thin enough crust to stand up to the toppings, and enough of a chew that it isn't a cracker texture. The garlic knots had a golden brown color and a good amount of garlic. It came with a cheesy nacho cheese and a garlicky tomato sauce. Tonight I decided to order the cheese calzone. I've never had one at Manhattan Pizzeria, and I'm not sure why. I was pleasantly surprised to see that it was fried not baked. It created a crispy exterior and a soft interior. It was chock full of Ricotta and Mozzarella cheese. The ricotta could have been seasoned more. ”
“ I've traveled the world and had pizza everywhere. I even been to New Jersey and New York and had many options for pizza..this pizza was creative with slices so I tried 3. The worst was the chicken, second pepperoni..the best one was a white slice and I give it 7 out of 10. The bottom crust was little too thin. ”
“ My dad & I always come to Manhattan when we are in the area and they have never disappointed! Authentic NY Style Pizza slices that are large, not super greasy and full of flavor! They also have a large menu that offers Pizza, Pasta, Sides, Subs, Wings, Desserts & Soda/Water! For a whole Pie/Pizza it cost around $19 or so dollars and for a slice it ranges anywhere between $3-4! If you are ever in the area, come check it out! #AccordingToArmon ”
Menu
Wings (10 Pieces)
$12.49Wings (5 Pieces)
$7.49Sicilian with Cheese
Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
About the Place
Manhattan Pizzeria
Manhattan Pizzeria in Indianapolis stands out as a genuine slice of New York right in the heart of Indiana. Known for its authentic NY-style pizza, this spot nails the balance between a crispy outer crust and a soft, chewy inside—an essential feature for any true New York pizza lover. The pizzas here are thoughtfully crafted, with just the right amount of tangy tomato sauce, gooey cheese, and fresh toppings that hold firm without overwhelming the crust.
What truly elevates the experience at Manhattan Pizzeria is not only the food but also the welcoming atmosphere. The clean, wood-accented space adorned with tasteful wall art feels inviting without being noisy, making it a perfect spot to watch your pizza being hand-tossed and baked to perfection. The staff adds a personal touch with their friendly and efficient service, even accommodating Spanish-speaking guests, which enhances that neighborhood pizzeria feeling.
The menu goes beyond just pizza, offering a solid variety of wings, subs, pastas, and desserts, catering to diverse tastes while maintaining reasonable prices. Whether grabbing a quick slice or ordering a whole pie, diners can expect quality and consistency. The tomato dipping sauce, rich with garlic, is a memorable finishing touch that many find addictive. For those who appreciate classic NY-style flavor and generous portions without the greasy overload, Manhattan Pizzeria is a reliable and satisfying choice.
While not every slice pleases every palate, the overall consensus points to a spot that delivers on flavor, value, and authenticity. For anyone craving a true taste of New York pizza—from locals to travelers seeking comfort food with character—Manhattan Pizzeria is well worth a visit.
Reserve Your Spot